Justice Thomas Makes It Clear He’s Not Happy With Supremes Who Rejected Florida Lawsuit
Justice Clarence Thomas doesn’t say much during oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court. He’s also got a calm demeanor and a hearty laugh.
And he’s been one of the best additions to the court in its distinguished history. He knows the Constitution like the back of his hand. So when a decision is made that seems injurious to the nation’s founding document, he responds like a parent trying to protect a child.
Thomas took other justices to task on Tuesday after a majority of the court refused to hear a lawsuit brought by Florida against Washington and California:
Justice Clarence Thomas accused California and Washington of undermining federal immigration and trucking safety standards after a deadly Florida highway crash, blasting the Supreme Court on Tuesday for refusing to hear a case Florida had “nowhere else to bring.”
Florida alleged the two blue states improperly issued commercial driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants in violation of federal standards requiring English proficiency and lawful immigration status for certain commercial drivers, arguing the policies created a public safety threat on American roads.
Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, said the Supreme Court had a constitutional obligation to hear the dispute because lawsuits between states can only be brought before the high court.
“If this Court does not exercise jurisdiction over a controversy between two States, then the complaining State has no judicial forum in which to seek relief,” Thomas wrote.
There’s only one court in the country that can hear lawsuits between states, and that’s the Supreme Court.
More:
Thomas argued that Florida’s allegations against Washington and California were serious because failing to follow federal commercial licensing laws can create dangerous road conditions and, he said, has contributed to deadly crashes.
Thomas pointed to the fatal Florida highway crash involving truck driver Harjinder Singh, who he said “could not read the road signs,” and argued Florida deserved a chance to pursue its claims.
People in the country illegally who can’t read road signs in English can’t be allowed to drive 80,000-pound tractor-trailers on American highways, he said.
“Federal law and regulations prohibit States from providing commercial driver’s licenses to applicants unless they pass a driver’s test, sufficiently understand the English language, and show appropriate immigration status,” Thomas noted.
Thomas wrote that while the court may exercise discretion when deciding whether to hear ordinary appeals, disputes between states stand on different constitutional footing.
“We have no more right to decline the exercise of jurisdiction which is given, than to usurp that which is not given,” Thomas wrote.
He’s right, of course. Florida now has no other recourse to pursue legal claims for the deaths of three of its residents. So not only were those deaths in vain, the two blue states who issued the Indian trucker a license get off scot-free.
It’s an outrageous development; Thomas and Alito are right to be upset about it. More than that, we have seven justices who think it’s okay to ignore a basic function of the high court: Settling disputes between states.
Chapter 1: The Secret in the Bathroom
Chapter 1: The Secret in the Bathroom
The groom's heart pounded as he looked into the little girl's frightened eyes.
"Sweetheart," he said softly, kneeling beside her, "what's your name?"
The girl hesitated before whispering, "Emily."
"Emily, why did your mom tell you to hide?"
Tears streamed down her cheeks.
"She said... if you saw me, the wedding would be ruined."
A cold chill ran down his spine.
The wedding would be ruined?
He glanced at the tiny princess dress she was wearing. It looked carefully chosen, almost as if she had been meant to be part of the ceremony.
Then Emily reached into her pocket and pulled out a folded photograph.
"Mom said I can't show this to anyone..."
The groom unfolded it.
His blood turned to ice.
It was a picture of him.
Holding a newborn baby.
On the back was written:
"Daddy's first day with Emily."
The date was six years ago.
The groom stared at the photo in disbelief.
He had never seen it before.
But somehow... it was undeniably him.
And suddenly, he realized there was only one person who could explain it.
The bride.
Chapter 2: A Truth Buried for Years
The groom stormed out of the bathroom and found his fiancée in a private room preparing for the ceremony.
When she saw the photograph in his hand, all color drained from her face.
"Where did you get that?" she whispered.
"Who is Emily?" he demanded.
The bride's eyes filled with tears.
For several seconds she couldn't speak.
Then she finally broke down.
"She's my daughter."
The room fell silent.
"You have a daughter?" he asked.
She nodded.
"I was terrified to tell you."
The bride explained that years earlier, during a brief separation in their relationship, she had become pregnant.
At the time she believed he had moved on.
Fear, shame, and uncertainty led her to raise the child alone.
When they reunited years later, she wanted to tell him the truth.
Again and again.
But every time she tried, she lost her courage.
"I thought if you knew, you'd leave."
The groom felt betrayed.
Not because she had a daughter.
But because she had hidden such a huge part of her life.
Then another question struck him.
"Why does Emily think I'm her father?"
The bride looked away.
Because there was one more secret she hadn't revealed.
Chapter 3: The Final Revelation
With trembling hands, the bride opened an old box she had kept hidden for years.
Inside were letters, photographs, and a DNA test.
She handed them to him.
The groom read the results.
His knees nearly gave out.
Probability of paternity:
99.99%.
Emily was his daughter.
His daughter.
The little girl he had just met in the bathroom.
The little girl who had spent years wondering why her father was never there.
The bride collapsed into tears.
"I wanted to tell you so many times."
"I was afraid."
"I thought you'd hate me."
The groom stood frozen.
Every emotion imaginable crashed through him.
Shock.
Anger.
Confusion.
Heartbreak.
And finally...
Love.
Not for the secret.
But for the little girl who had done nothing wrong.
He thought about Emily sitting alone in that bathroom, hiding because she believed her existence would destroy the wedding.
At that moment, he made his decision.
Ending: The Wedding No One Expected
Minutes later, the guests stood and turned as the music began.
But something was different.
The groom wasn't standing alone.
Beside him was Emily.
Holding his hand.
The entire room watched in silence.
The bride entered and immediately burst into tears when she saw them together.
The groom smiled gently.
Then he knelt before Emily.
"So you don't have to hide anymore."
The little girl stared at him.
"Really?"
He nodded.
"No more secrets."
"No more hiding."
"And if it's okay with you..."
His voice cracked with emotion.
"I'd like to spend the rest of my life being your dad."
Emily threw her arms around his neck and cried harder than ever.
This time, not from fear.
But from happiness.
The guests wiped tears from their eyes as father and daughter embraced for the first time.
The wedding continued.
Not as the perfect ceremony everyone had planned.
But as something far more meaningful.
Because that day, a man didn't just gain a wife.
He found the daughter he never knew he had.
And a little girl who had been told to stay hidden finally learned she was loved, wanted, and never had to hide again.
